The advertising industry has long operated on the principle that creative agencies, like adult children, do better when they believe they are making their own choices — even when the holding company is quietly paying the rent.
That delicate fiction has become harder to sustain at Omnicom Group, where the creative advertising units are contending with an accumulation of difficulties in the year since the company completed its acquisition of Interpublic Group of Cos. Leadership departures have accelerated, questions about agency autonomy have grown more pointed, and the twin pressures of client retention and talent retention have begun to press against each other in ways that tend to produce departures of both.
The merger, announced with the usual assurances about preserving the distinctive cultures of the acquired agencies, has instead produced something closer to an identity crisis, according to people at several of the affected shops. (The assurances, it should be noted, are always the same; the outcomes vary.)
For Omnicom, which under John D. Wren has spent three decades assembling one of the industry's largest collections of agency brands, the challenge is a familiar one made unfamiliar by scale. Integrating a competitor the size of Interpublic — itself a holding company with decades of accumulated acquisitions, loyalties and client conflicts — requires a kind of organizational finesse that becomes exponentially harder when the people who are supposed to execute it keep leaving.
The situation is not helped by the broader climate on Madison Avenue, where marketer budgets remain cautious and the conversation in every new-business pitch eventually turns to artificial intelligence, whether or not anyone in the room knows precisely what they mean by it.
Omnicom executives have maintained that the integration is proceeding as planned, a statement that is technically unfalsifiable and therefore difficult to argue with.
What happens next will depend, as it usually does, on whether the clients stay — and on whether the clients have anywhere else they particularly want to go.
Original story published in adage.com: "Omnicom creative agencies face an identity crisis after IPG deal - Ad Age"