The sausage factory of Madison Avenue has always operated behind closed doors, but the newer wing — the one where influencer deals are assembled — has been particularly opaque, perhaps because the people doing the assembling are still figuring out where everything goes.
That veil lifted somewhat last week when Hadley Musinsky, director of influence and advocacy at YSL Beauty, and Sophie Bressler, a talent manager at the firm Night, described the mechanics of their negotiations during a podcast recording at a Digiday virtual event. The two have worked together for more than a decade, which in influencer marketing terms makes them practically institutional.
The process, it turns out, begins much as advertising always has: with a brief. "Whenever we have a launch or a business priority, we'll talk through where do we need support, who do we want support from and what does that really look like," Ms. Musinsky said. She then brings creator names to managers like Ms. Bressler, who evaluates whether her clients can actually deliver what the brand wants.
"If Hadley says to me, 'We're really looking to drive sales,' I don't want to put forward a client who doesn't have a history of strong link clicks on Instagram Stories," Ms. Bressler said. (One imagines the same principle applied when casting for soap operas, though the metrics were murkier then.)
What follows is a negotiation over the usual pressure points: exclusivity, usage rights, which platforms will carry the content, and eventually money. YSL Beauty typically asks for syndication across Instagram, TikTok and YouTube Shorts, plus two weeks of paid usage rights upfront. Ms. Bressler noted that even without formal exclusivity, a creator appearing in paid ads for one luxury beauty brand may find other luxury beauty brands suddenly less interested — a kind of phantom exclusivity that she said must be factored into the rate.
Ms. Musinsky acknowledged that YSL Beauty is not, for the most part, tracking direct sales from influencer posts. "For us, it's usually more of an awareness play," she said, "or as we call it, a virality moment."
The terminology is new. The aspiration — to get people talking — is as old as the industry itself.
Original story published in Digiday: "Anatomy of an influencer marketing deal"