There is a moment in every campaign when someone remembers the tote bags.

It arrives late, usually after the media plan has been finalized and the creative has been approved, when a junior account person is asked to source something — anything — that can be handed out at the launch event. The remaining budget is modest. The timeline is immodest. The result is predictable.

Drew Holmgreen, the president and chief executive of the Promotional Products Association International, would like agencies to reconsider this sequence. In an argument that will be familiar to anyone who has ever received a branded fleece vest and worn it for years afterward, Mr. Holmgreen suggests that merchandise deserves a place in the creative brief rather than the budget's clearance aisle.

"What could we give someone that earns a place in their life and furthers our brand message?" is the question Mr. Holmgreen proposes, which is more ambitious than the traditional formulation: "Can we get 500 of these by Thursday?"

The association, which represents the promotional products industry, has released research to support the case. A study of more than 3,400 consumers found that 96 percent of recipients keep branded merchandise, and 89 percent reported using the items regularly or occasionally. (The study does not specify how many of those items are currently wadded in a desk drawer, though one suspects the number is not zero.)

More telling, perhaps, is the finding that design and appearance influenced first impressions for 51 percent of respondents, compared with 37 percent for the brand name or logo itself. The implication is that a well-made product may do more work than the mark printed on it — a notion that challenges agencies to think of merchandise as creative output rather than creative afterthought.

Mr. Holmgreen's prescription is straightforward: assign the merchandise a job, involve a specialist early, and resist the temptation to treat the baseball cap as merely a surface for the logo.

Whether agencies will embrace this advice remains to be seen. Old habits, like old tote bags, have a way of persisting.

Original story published in Adweek: "Stop Putting Branded Merchandise at the End of the Brief"