In the spring of 2016, two employees of BuzzFeed, clad in lab coats and safety goggles, sat before a camera and began wrapping rubber bands around a watermelon. They kept going, band after band, until the fruit exploded. More than three million people were said to have watched. CNBC declared it the future of television.

It was not, as it turns out, the future of television. It was something else entirely: a glimpse of an industry that had begun measuring the wrong thing and could not figure out how to stop.

The algorithms that governed digital advertising were given a simple instruction — maximize revenue — and they did exactly that, producing and promoting whatever generated the most impressions. An impression, in the accounting of the era, was counted each time an ad appeared on a screen for a few seconds, whether or not anyone actually looked at it. (Whether they were conscious, for that matter, went unasked.)

This created what the authors of a new analysis call "a subprime market for human attention." As the supply of these phantom impressions exploded, prices fell for every seller of advertising, including television networks whose commercials were graded by an entirely different standard. Scrolling past an exploding watermelon on a phone was treated the same as watching every minute of a World Series game.

The networks responded as one might expect: they ran more commercials, which made the viewing experience worse, which pushed more viewers toward streaming platforms with no commercials at all. Some experimented with cutting ad loads and offering six-second spots, which required explaining to media buyers why six seconds should cost more than thirty. The real estate industry understood scarcity. Madison Avenue, it seemed, still wanted volume.

The result, as described by the authors — one of whom oversaw advertising at Fox Networks Group during this period — was a vicious cycle in which the industry manufactured ever more impressions to compensate for the declining value of each one. The watermelon, one might say, was not the only thing being squeezed.

Original story published in Fast Company: "How advertising machines broke the attention economy"