The last time a new category of wagering tried to elbow its way into the national conversation during a major sporting event, the strategy involved a lot of celebrity endorsers and a willingness to spend money as if it were, well, other people's money. The prediction market platforms now circling the Super Bowl appear to have studied that playbook carefully.
Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig — platforms that let users buy and sell contracts on the outcomes of events ranging from elections to, presumably, whether it will rain on Tuesday — are coming off what might be called a successful tryout. During the midterm elections, they collectively handled nearly $1.9 billion in wagers, according to an analysis by The Washington Post, and Kalshi says its favored candidates won 98 percent of resolved races.
(The platforms did miss a few things, including the defeat of Gov. Greg Abbott in Texas, but perfection has never been a requirement for claiming victory in the forecasting business.)
The midterm push was not subtle. Kalshi bought a billboard in Times Square displaying Senate odds, as if it were a polling firm with a flair for the dramatic. Polymarket enlisted Kathryn Bigelow, the director of "The Hurt Locker," to make spots that dramatized fictional scenarios involving grocery prices — not the typical creative brief for a betting platform, but then again, these are not typical betting platforms, or so their marketing would have you believe.
The next test arrives Feb. 14, when the Super Bowl lands in New Orleans. The National Football League, which has historically been protective of its broadcast inventory, has barred prediction markets from advertising during the game, in stadiums and in deals with players. This leaves the platforms to pursue what might be called the ambient strategy: pop-up activations in Los Angeles, influencer campaigns and, in Kalshi's case, running markets on the advertisements themselves.
At last year's Super Bowl, Kalshi's market on which brands would advertise generated $72.2 million in volume — a tidy sum for a platform betting on other people's commercials.
Whether this counts as a breakthrough or merely an expensive workaround remains to be seen. The category faces lawsuits in New York and Utah, a turf war between the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and state regulators, and polling that suggests most Americans view these platforms as gambling operations and oppose betting on elections.
Then again, the sports betting apps faced similar headwinds not so long ago, and now their commercials are as much a part of football Sundays as the games themselves.
Original story published in Adweek: "ADWEEK Brand Advantage: Prediction Markets Grabbed Midterm Attention. The Super Bowl Is Their Next Branding Test"