The received wisdom of modern marketing holds that a brand without a roster of content creators is a brand falling behind. Guinness, the storied Irish stout that has been around since 1759, appears not to have received this particular memo — or, more likely, to have filed it somewhere in the back of a drawer.
Paddy Carberry, the global marketing manager and head of sport at Guinness, which is owned by the spirits giant Diageo, laid out his thinking during a recent recording of the Unofficial Partner podcast, produced in partnership with the agency Sid Lee. The gist: the brand has no intention of signing up creators in bulk, because doing so would risk making Guinness look like, in Mr. Carberry's evocative phrase, "the dad dancing at the disco."
This is a brand, after all, that rebuilt much of its cultural capital the old-fashioned way — by extending credit to struggling publicans during the pandemic lockdowns and sending unsold beer off to fertilize Christmas trees. The gesture was noticed by the people who pull pints for a living, and Mr. Carberry believes their goodwill matters more than a thousand sponsored posts ever could.
Creators have nonetheless played a role in the revival, though mostly without a Diageo brief attached. London's pint-rating accounts turned the judgment of other people's pours into a minor spectator sport. Kim Kardashian and Olivia Rodrigo provided the sort of endorsements that money cannot buy (because no money changed hands). And "Splitting the G" — the ritual of sipping a pint so the foam line bisects the Guinness logo — had been circulating in pubs since at least 2018, when it earned an Urban Dictionary entry.
When the brand does touch creator culture, it does so gingerly. Its 2023 "Singing Pints" campaign, recently revived, borrowed from a TikTok trend in which pubgoers poked faces into the foam and blew across them. "We took what was the consumer playing with the brand and amplified it into a TV spot," Mr. Carberry said. "That was one of our most successful pieces of content for the last ten years."
The approach puts Guinness closer to where influencer marketing began — back when brands courted bloggers with small but devoted readerships rather than chasing follower counts like stock prices. The industry spent the better part of a decade turning those relationships into a reach game. Guinness still plays, but carefully.
(The brand also faces constraints that most marketers do not: in Britain, anyone drinking in an alcohol advertisement must be, and appear to be, over 25, and a brand cannot advertise anywhere more than a quarter of the audience is under 18. TikTok's demographics make that promise difficult to keep.)
Jon Williams, the founder and chief creative officer of the agency Freedom Works, offered a generous interpretation. "Guinness might not consciously be signing people up as creators," he said, "but 'Splitting the G' has turned plenty of ordinary drinkers into exactly that."
Which may be the point. A brand that has been pouring pints for two and a half centuries can afford to let the glass do the talking.
Original story published in Digiday: "Future of Marketing Briefing: Inside Guinness' go-slow approach to creators"