There was a time when the phrase "handmade" in advertising meant pottery, or perhaps a particularly earnest granola. This holiday season, it appears to mean something closer to "not made by a machine that learned to write copy by reading the entire internet."

A quiet but unmistakable trend has emerged in the annual crop of holiday campaigns: brands are taking considerable pains to emphasize human craft, human creativity, human hands doing human things. The word "artificial" appears nowhere in these advertisements, which is precisely the point. The anxiety need not speak its name to be heard.

The phenomenon arrives at a moment when the advertising industry finds itself in an extended conversation — some would call it an argument, others a negotiation conducted in press releases — about the role of generative artificial intelligence in the creative process. Holding companies have made bold pronouncements about efficiency gains. Creative directors have made somewhat less bold pronouncements about their continued relevance. And now, it seems, brands have decided that the safest position is to simply show a person holding a pencil.

(Whether the strategy documents behind these campaigns were themselves drafted with algorithmic assistance is a question best left unasked at holiday parties.)

Apple, which has built an empire on the notion that technology should feel less like technology, has released a holiday film featuring a boy and his relationship to art — the making-things-with-your-hands variety, not the type-a-prompt-and-wait variety. The company did not respond to requests for comment on whether this represented an official position on the matter.

Other advertisers joining the handcrafted chorus include Levi's, Dunkin', e.l.f. Beauty, and Calvin Klein, according to industry observers, though the specifics of their human-forward messaging vary.

It is, of course, possible that brands have simply rediscovered an affection for craft that predates the current technological moment. It is also possible that reindeer will learn to fly unassisted.

Original story published in adweek.com: "Human-Crafted Holiday Ads Are an Unspoken Nod to AI Anxiety"