The business of paying people with followings to say nice things about products is not exactly new. What is new, or at least newly fashionable, is the notion that a brand might greenlight an entire show rather than simply book a post.

Pooja Tripathi, the creator behind "Brooklyn Coffee Shop," a comedy web series about an opinionated barista, has become something of a test case. SharkNinja wrote its Auto Barista machine into an episode. Anthropologie went considerably further, hiring Ms. Tripathi to write and direct its first comedy series — a holiday party caper that the retailer is treating, in the words of its global chief executive, Barbra Sainsurin, "like a movie launch." (One suspects the catering budget was somewhat smaller.)

The series, "The Holiday Party," consists of 90-second episodes that began appearing on the brand's social channels this month. Ms. Tripathi developed the characters and story; Anthropologie's team handled the styling, down to how the party was decorated. The goal, Ms. Sainsurin said, was a setting that felt true to Ms. Tripathi's audience while also looking like "a party that an Anthro person would throw."

This is not an isolated experiment. A British production company called Rooscreen has created "We Are MICE," a mockumentary set at a fictional events agency, with real brands written into the plot as clients. Laura Geller Beauty commissioned the first six episodes. The format is designed to rotate sponsors while the characters — played by creators — carry their storylines forward.

The arrangement reopens one of the industry's recurring debates: whether influencer marketing and creator marketing are different disciplines or simply different price points. Both pay someone with an audience to put a product in front of it. But influencer marketing leans on the person; creator marketing leans on the content itself — characters viewers return to, formats that outlast a single scroll.

Pricing such work remains, as one talent manager put it, "its own puzzle." Victoria Bachan, chief executive of Hyphen, a talent management firm, said a multi-episode series lands "well into five figures," with usage rights and exclusivity pushing some deals to six.

Whether this represents the future of brand storytelling or simply its latest detour will depend, as these things always do, on the numbers. Anthropologie's team is watching earned reach, saves, shares and eventually sales. "We Are MICE" has logged 1.3 million views on Instagram so far.

Becky Rooney, Rooscreen's founder, offered the kind of observation that tends to follow early success: "Going viral is one thing, but if that means reaching two million people who don't want to buy the product, does that have as much value as reaching 20,000 people who actually do?"

It is a reasonable question. It is also the sort of question the advertising business has been asking itself, in various forms, since approximately 1952.

Original story published in Digiday: "Brands go from booking creators to green-lighting shows", by Seb Joseph, Krystal Scanlon