The house of Dior has found itself in the peculiar position of having to defend the authenticity of its own Christmas card.

The luxury brand's holiday film, directed by the Oscar-nominated animator Sylvain Chomet and promoted as an entirely hand-drawn tribute to traditional animation techniques, has become the subject of what might be called a crowdsourced forensic investigation. Users on social media platforms have been examining the work frame by frame, flagging what they consider telltale signs of artificial intelligence: a Marlene Dietrich with six fingers, the warped lettering of a signature, hands that seem to lose or gain digits between frames.

Mr. Chomet and his producer, Aton Soumache, have denied that generative AI was used in the production, while acknowledging that automated interpolation — a technique for generating the frames between key drawings — was part of the process. Mr. Chomet described this as "a way of automating the repetitive, mechanical part of animation, not the creative work." He also noted that a moving hand might show six or seven fingers intentionally, "because you're trying to convey movement."

(One imagines Walt Disney's animators never anticipated their craft would one day require a public relations explanation.)

The controversy is particularly pointed because Dior had made the hand-drawn nature of the film a selling point. Jonathan Anderson, the brand's creative director, described it as using "techniques that go back to the 1940s." When the accusations surfaced, Dior released a behind-the-scenes video featuring Mr. Chomet and production sketches, which only prompted further questions about why sketches were shown rather than the animation process itself.

Geoff Desreumaux, a vice president at Dentsu Creative, suggested the real issue was one of trust. "If a brand says something is 'hand-drawn,' then the process becomes part of the story," he wrote. "And for a luxury brand like Dior, that matters even more."

Dior is not alone in this predicament. Gucci faced similar criticism in March over promotional images it had disclosed were AI-generated but which consumers still found distasteful for a brand built on craftsmanship.

The lesson, it seems, is that in an age of artificial everything, the fingerprints had better be real — even if there are only five of them.

Original story published in campaignlive.com: "Dior’s holiday film sparks debate on alleged AI use over ‘hand-drawn’ claims | Campaign US"